Topic 2: Abby, AJ, Amy, Celeste

The Catcher in the Rye is the tenth most frequently challenged book from 1990-1999, and again in 2005. In total, it has been the third most challenged book. Most of the challenges are because of vulgar language, blasphemy, undermining family and moral values, encouragement of rebellion, and promoting drinking, smoking, and promiscuity, but with sexual content being the biggest reason. Three assassinations occurred, including Mark David Chapman’s shooting of John Lennon, with the assassin having a copy of the book on their person. This has brought up a lot of controversy toward the book.

The book also challenged many values in the 1950’s. It features Holden as an outspoken teen, which many some people can connect with. This is because he recognizes negativity in society and helps the helpless. Most teens go throw identity crisis’ where they don’t know who they are. Holden alienated himself from society, where people don’t understand and no one is truly honest. Betrayal is also a big factor. Most teen boys don’t mature as well as ladies do in high school. This book really relates to teen’s lives and the language Holden speaks is what most teens say anyway, so one can really connect to Holden. Teens in the 1950’s also thought it shouldn’t be banned because they though it related to problems they had. Many of them have similar feelings as Holden does: against the aspects of life.

When the book was first published, the publishers had strong feelings for it’s readers. Many said it reflects the conflicted feelings and emotions of teenagers. Some say it does encourage the rebellious. Other critics say Holden is being an innocent adrift in a troubled world. Others blame him for inspiring discord in adolescence.